Nighttime Photosynthesis: How CAM Plants Thrive on Scarcity
- Foliage Factory
- 8 hours ago
- 26 min read
Why CAM Matters for Your Plants
Night-Breathing Houseplants
Why does your jade plant thrive after weeks without water while your fern wilts if you miss a single watering? Why do orchids demand cool nights to bloom, when monsteras don’t? The answer is a very different kind of photosynthesis.
Most common houseplants are C₃ “day breathers.” They open their stomata in daylight, take in carbon dioxide, and turn it directly into sugars. But a select group of plants — including many succulents such as cacti, jade plants and aloes, plus air plants, bromeliads, certain orchids, and tough survivors like snake plant — flipped the schedule millions of years ago. Not every succulent runs CAM, and some thin-leaved epiphytes and even ferns can use it, but the common thread is shifting gas exchange to the night (Smith & Winter 1996; Holtum & Winter 1999; Heyduk 2022).”
This strategy is called Crassulacean Acid Metabolism (CAM), named for the Crassulaceae family (jade plants, kalanchoës) where it was first studied. By shifting gas exchange into the cooler, more humid hours of the night, CAM plants lose far less water while still producing the sugars they need.
For growers, that explains why:
succulents survive long droughts but grow slowly,
air plants respond best to an evening mist,
many orchids bloom more reliably with a night temperature drop,
snake plants forgive almost any neglect.
CAM is more than a survival trick indoors. It’s also inspiring scientists who want to design future crops that can thrive with less water in a warming world. And understanding CAM is the difference between overwatering your jade into rot and letting it thrive on scarcity
Contents:
The Science of CAM Photosynthesis
A Two-Shift Workday for Plants
Instead of photosynthesising continuously like C₃ plants, CAM species run a day/night split shift:
Night (Phase I): Stomata open, CO₂ flows in, and the enzyme PEP carboxylase captures it. The carbon is converted into malic acid and stored in large vacuoles. By dawn, the leaf interior is measurably more acidic.
Day (Phase III): Stomata shut tight. Stored malic acid is broken down, releasing CO₂ right next to Rubisco, which runs the Calvin cycle to make sugars. Light powers the reaction, but no new air is exchanged.
➜ Result: photosynthesis continues in daylight without losing water.
🔗 Curious how these tiny pores actually work across different plant groups? Our guide to stomata explains their role in gas exchange and water control in simple terms: What are stomata and why do they matter for houseplants?
The Four Phases of a CAM Cycle
Botanists divide CAM into four daily phases:
Phase I (Night): Stomata open, CO₂ fixed, acids stored.
Phase II (Dawn): Some species briefly keep stomata ajar for extra CO₂ uptake as light rises.
Phase III (Day): Stomata closed, acids decarboxylated, sugars built.
Phase IV (Late Afternoon): In some species, stomata reopen briefly before dusk.
💡Under extreme drought, Phases I & IV may disappear — stomata stay closed day and night, and the plant recycles only its own respiratory CO₂. This survival mode is called CAM-idling.
Quantitative WUE + Carbon Trade-offs
One reason CAM plants are so effective is their water-use efficiency. Studies show they fix carbon with three to six times less water loss than C₃ plants. That’s why agaves and cacti can thrive in habitats where grasses or crops collapse. The trade-off is speed: CAM plants typically capture only a tenth of the daily carbon gain of a well-watered C₃ plant. In practice, that means incredible survival under scarcity but much slower growth compared to faster “day-breathers.”
By the Numbers — CAM in Figures
Water-use efficiency (WUE): typically 2.6–20 times higher than C₃ plants, and in some cases up to about 40 times (Lüttge 2004; BioNumbers BNID 100673).
Daily carbon gain: generally lower than in C₃ plants, but variable. Obligate CAM succulents may reach rates comparable to C₃ species when water is plentiful, while facultative CAM species may contribute less than 10–20 percent of their carbon through the night cycle under stress (Winter & Smith 1996; Herrera 2008; Portulaca study: Moreno-Villena et al. 2022).
δ¹³C signature: typically –29 to –11‰, overlapping both C₃ plants (–34 to –24‰) and C₄ plants (–15 to –9‰). CAM values shift along this range depending on the proportion of nocturnal versus daytime CO₂ uptake (Osmond et al. 1996; Winter & Smith 1996; Holtum & Winter 1999).
➜ Translation for growers: CAM plants are water savers, not sprinters.
🔗 Some houseplants even expel excess water at night — a process called guttation — which is another way plants manage moisture balance. Guttation in plants: why your leaves drip water at night
Enzymes Behind the Cycle
CAM relies on a carefully timed enzyme toolkit:
PEP carboxylase (PEPC): Night-time CO₂ capture.
Malate transporters: Move acids into vacuoles.
Decarboxylases: Release CO₂ by day. Different lineages use different enzymes — e.g. cacti often rely on NADP-malic enzyme, some orchids on PEPCK.
Rubisco: Runs the Calvin cycle in daylight, fed by internal CO₂.
This variation (NADP-ME vs. NAD-ME vs. PEPCK types) shows CAM isn’t one rigid pathway — it has evolved multiple times with different biochemical “solutions.” This biochemical diversity shows CAM evolved multiple times, converging on the same survival strategy
A Built-In Circadian Clock
CAM is tightly linked to a plant’s internal clock. Gene networks tied to circadian rhythm control when stomata open and when enzymes switch on. This explains why many orchids and bromeliads perform best if nights are clearly cooler than days: without that daily signal, their rhythm blurs and CAM runs less efficiently.
How Scientists Spot CAM Plants
Researchers confirm CAM activity in two main ways:
Overnight acidification: Leaves become more acidic by morning as malic acid accumulates.
Carbon isotope fingerprint (δ¹³C): One of the clearest scientific markers of CAM is its carbon isotope signature. CAM plants usually show δ¹³C values between –29 and –11‰, depending on how much carbon is fixed at night. This overlaps with both C₃ plants (–34 to –24‰) and C₄ plants (–15 to –9‰). The more negative the value, the more C₃-like the behaviour; values closer to –11‰ indicate a stronger reliance on nocturnal CAM fixation (Osmond et al. 1996; Winter & Smith 1996; Holtum & Winter 1999).
➜ Grower takeaway: CAM plants essentially “save up carbon at night and spend it by day.” This rhythm makes them more drought-proof and heat-tolerant, but also caps their growth speed.
Evolution & Types of CAM
How and why CAM evolved
Convergent solution to the same problem: CAM has evolved independently dozens of times — at least 35, and possibly more than 60 — across about 36 families and over 400 genera (Smith & Winter 1996; Bräutigam et al. 2017; Sage et al. 2023). Overall, around 6 percent of vascular plant species show CAM to some degree (Lüttge 2004; Holtum 2023).
Primary driver: Water scarcity and high daytime VPD (hot, dry air that strips water from leaves). CAM shifts CO₂ uptake to the cooler, more humid night, slashing transpirational water loss.
Secondary drivers:
Intermittent water access (epiphytes on bark or rock, fog/dew rather than soil water).
Salinity or nutrient stress (e.g., coastal/alkaline substrates).
CO₂ limitation in specific niches (some aquatic/emersed plants).
High light/heat (CAM suppresses photorespiration by saturating Rubisco with internally released CO₂).
Anatomical preconditions: Many CAM plants are succulent (big vacuoles to store malic acid; thick cuticles; low surface:volume). Epiphytes can be less “fleshy” but still possess the storage/transport capacity to run the cycle.
Why CAM isn’t everywhere: There’s a throughput ceiling—daily photosynthesis is capped by how much CO₂ was banked at night. Add the extra ATP costs for moving/processing malate, and CAM loses to C₃/C₄ in lush, well-watered settings. Translation: phenomenal survivor, mediocre sprinter.
➜ Grower translation: CAM is what lets cacti, aloes, agaves, many bromeliads and orchids stay alive and even make sugars in brutal conditions that stall or kill C₃ foliage plants.
Degrees of CAM — it’s a dial, not an on/off switch
CAM expression is best seen as a continuum rather than a simple on/off switch. Some lineages are obligate night-breathers, others can shift metabolism depending on water or light stress, and many species fall somewhere in between.
A) Obligate CAM: Always use CAM once tissues are mature — e.g. most cacti, many agaves and aloes, and numerous bromeliads. Not every species within these genera is CAM, but most are strongly committed to it (Smith & Winter 1996; Lüttge 2004).
B) Facultative CAM: Normally behave as C₃ plants under comfortable, well-watered conditions but switch on CAM when stressed by drought, salinity or high irradiance. The shift can occur within days, and plants often revert once stress is relieved. Classic examples include Mesembryanthemum crystallinum, some Sedum, Clusia, Portulaca oleracea, and several orchids (Cushman & Borland 2002; Winter & Holtum 2014; Moreno-Villena et al. 2022).
C) CAM-cycling and CAM-idling: Survival modes where stomata open little or not at all, and internal CO₂ is recycled. These phases minimise water loss but also halt growth (Osmond et al. 1996).
D) Weak or partial CAM: Low-capacity systems where only a fraction of CO₂ is fixed at night. Houseplant examples include Dracaena trifasciata (snake plant), Zamioculcas, some Yucca, and some Hoya.
E) Dual systems: Some lineages combine CAM with another pathway, e.g. Clusia (C₃+CAM) or Portulaca oleracea (C₄+CAM). These cases show how flexible carbon metabolism can be (Moreno-Villena et al. 2022).
Importantly, CAM strength can shift not only between species but also within a single plant over time. For example, many seedlings germinate in C₃ mode and develop stronger CAM as tissues become more succulent (Winter & Holtum 2014).
What controls the dial (regulation)
Water status: Drought is the strongest, most reliable on-switch for CAM or higher CAM amplitude.
Salinity/nutrient stress: Salty or nutrient-poor substrates can induce or amplify CAM in facultative species.
Light & heat: High irradiance/heat makes daytime stomatal opening costly; CAM mitigates that.
Night temperature: Cooler nights (vs. days) reinforce stomatal rhythm; warm nights can dampen CAM amplitude in some species.
Developmental stage: Many species are C₃ when young and switch to CAM as tissues become succulent (e.g., seedlings of cacti).
Circadian clock: Gene networks time PEPC (night) and decarboxylases (day), aligning metabolism with the light–dark cycle; this is genetically hard-wired, then modulated by environment.
➜ Grower translation: You can’t “force speed” into a CAM plant with more fertilizer. You can help its rhythm by giving bright days, cooler nights, and real dry-downs.
Practical mapping — type → care expectations
Obligate CAM (cacti, agave, aloe, many Tillandsia):
Bright to full sun, deep soak then fully dry, minimal winter water, avoid cold-wet.
Expect slow, tidy growth; pushing water/fertilizer mostly invites rot.
Facultative CAM (ice plants, some sedums, some orchids, Clusia, Portulaca):
In comfort they drink a bit more and grow faster; under stress they tighten into CAM.
Manage by season: more water/light feed when actively growing; pull back hard in heat/drought/cool.
Epiphytic CAM (many orchids, Tillandsia, bromeliads):
Air around the roots, not muck. Evening soak/mist is most effective; dry by morning.
Night drop (~5–10 °C) improves rhythm and flowering in many orchids.
Weak CAM (snake plant, ZZ):
Beginner-proof: bright light preferred but tolerate low; infrequent watering; don’t oversell air-purifying claims.
Common pitfalls & reality checks
“They photosynthesise at night, so light doesn’t matter.” False. Daylight powers sugar production; night only banks CO₂. No light = no growth.
“‘Evening watering is always best.’ Misleading. For epiphytic CAM plants such as orchids, Tillandsia, and bromeliads, late-day or evening watering aligns with stomata opening and can improve uptake if leaves and roots dry again by morning (Osmond et al. 1996; Winter & Smith 1996). For desert succulents, timing matters far less than drainage and temperature: water sitting in cool conditions with poor airflow often leads to rot. The rule of thumb is to match the plant’s ecology — bark- or canopy-dwelling epiphytes respond to evening hydration, while desert CAM plants mainly need a full dry-down between waterings.
“All succulents are CAM.” Most, not all. Don’t assume—check your species.
“More fertilizer = more growth.” False. CAM imposes a built-in speed limit because carbon fixation depends on how much CO₂ was stored overnight, not nutrients. Growth is slower than in C₃ species, but the exact rate varies widely (Winter & Smith 1996; Herrera 2008).
➜ Net takeaway: CAM is not a monolith. It evolved repeatedly because it’s the best water-saving hack plants have. But it comes with a speed limit and shows up along a continuum—from full-time desert specialists to flexible switchers and low-capacity “survival modes.” If you know where on the dial your plant sits, you’ll nail its care: bright days, cooler nights, air around roots, and real dry-downs when the plant asks for them.
Houseplant Examples of CAM
CAM isn’t confined to desert succulents. It has evolved in very different lineages — from cacti and agaves to bromeliads, orchids, hoyas, clusias, even aquatic isoëtes and epiphytic ferns (Holtum & Winter 1999; Holtum 2023). Importantly, not every member of these groups runs CAM full-time: some Sedum, Peperomia, and rainforest orchids remain C₃. Knowing which category your plant falls into helps you predict its growth, water needs, and quirks indoors.
Succulent CAM Specialists — Drought Hardliners
Cacti (Cactaceae)
CAM type: Obligate — full CAM from seedling maturity onward.
Signature traits: Leafless, fleshy stems that double as water and acid storage tanks. Thick cuticle, spines for shade and defense.
Grower insight: Require bright sun, dry-downs between deep waterings, and protection from cold-wet soil. They’ll keep ticking in hot windows where tropicals collapse.
Aloe & Agave
CAM type: Obligate.
Traits: Rosettes of fleshy leaves with large vacuoles.
Grower insight: Let soil dry fully; don’t crowd the crown with water. Growth is slow but reliable, even in shallow, rocky pots.
Crassula ovata (Jade plant)
CAM type: Obligate; namesake of CAM’s discovery.
Traits: Fleshy oval leaves; sap acidity rises overnight.
Grower insight: Bright light + infrequent deep watering = compact, glossy growth. Overwatering makes leaves split or drop.
Echeveria & Sedum (stonecrops)
CAM type: Many obligate; some Sedum are facultative.
Grower insight: Classic rosette succulents; thrive on dry cycles. Some Sedum may grow faster in mild conditions then flip into CAM when stressed.
Euphorbia succulents (e.g., Euphorbia trigona)
CAM type: Obligate.
Traits: Cactus-like stems but with toxic latex sap.
Grower insight: Treat as cactus — sunny, spare watering, but handle carefully (sap irritant).
Epiphytic CAM Plants — Surviving Without Soil
Tillandsia (Air plants)
CAM type: Obligate.
Traits: No roots for soil uptake; leaves absorb water/CO₂ via trichomes.
Grower insight: Mist/soak late afternoon or evening, when stomata are open. Always ensure good airflow so they dry by morning.
Orchids (Phalaenopsis, Dendrobium, Cattleya, Oncidium)
CAM type: Many are facultative CAM — switchable depending on water and light.
Traits: Thick leaves and pseudobulbs store water and acids.
Grower insight: A night drop of 5–10 °C often boosts flowering and CAM rhythm. Evening watering aligns with open stomata. Use bark or other airy substrate. Not all orchids are CAM — rainforest species often remain C₃.
Bromeliads (Guzmania, Aechmea, Vriesea)
CAM type: Mostly obligate.
Traits: Rosettes with central tanks for water; leathery leaves.
Grower insight: Keep water in the central cup, not soggy soil. Moderate humidity + airflow mimic canopy life.
Pineapple (Ananas comosus)
CAM type: Obligate CAM crop.
Traits: Rosette bromeliad with fibrous leaves.
Grower insight: Indoors, needs bright light and moderate watering. Important research model for CAM genetics.
Hoya (Wax plants)
CAM type: Partial/facultative CAM.
Traits: Waxy leaves, vining epiphyte.
Grower insight: Let soil dry between waterings. Airflow and a mild night drop support CAM phases and flowering.
Clusia
CAM type: Facultative — runs C₃ in comfort, switches to CAM under drought or strong light.
Traits: Thick, leathery leaves; shrubby growth; adaptable indoors.
Grower insight: Grows steadily in good soil and humidity, but under stress flips into CAM mode for survival. Flexible and resilient, though behaviour varies with environment.
Forgiving “Weak CAM” Houseplants
Snake plant (Dracaena trifasciata, formerly Sansevieria)
CAM type: Weak CAM.
Traits: Sword-like fleshy leaves, minimal stomatal opening.
Grower insight: Survives neglect thanks to low-level CAM. Needs bright light for best growth, but tolerates dim corners. Releases small amounts of O₂ at night — real, but trivial for air quality.
ZZ plant (Zamioculcas zamiifolia)
CAM type: Weak/stress-induced.
Traits: Glossy pinnate leaves; rhizomes store water and acids.
Grower insight: Infamous for surviving in offices. Water rarely; overwatering rots rhizomes faster than CAM can save them.
Yucca
CAM type: Some species show partial CAM.
Grower insight: Stiff rosettes with fibrous leaves. Bright light, dry cycles. Tolerant but not as indestructible as snake plant.
Non-arid CAM (aquatic + ferns)
CAM isn’t confined to desert cacti. It has evolved multiple times in unrelated lineages — from agaves and aloes to bromeliads, orchids, hoyas, clusias, even some aquatic isoëtes and epiphytic ferns (Holtum & Winter 1999; Holtum 2023). But not every member of these groups runs CAM: some Sedum and Peperomia are C₃, and many rainforest orchids remain strictly C₃. Checking the species is key.
Quick Reference Table
Plants | CAM Type | Key Care Insight |
|---|---|---|
Cacti (barrel, prickly pear) | Obligate | Full sun, deep soak then dry; avoid cold + wet. |
Aloe, Agave | Obligate | Bright light, dry cycles; protect crown from rot. |
Crassula (Jade plant) | Obligate | Infrequent deep watering; compact growth in strong light. |
Echeveria, Sedum | Obligate/Facultative | Dry cycles; some Sedum switch into CAM under stress. ❗ Some Sedum remain C₃, so not all show CAM. |
Euphorbia succulents | Obligate | Treat like cacti; toxic latex sap requires care. |
Tillandsia (Air plants) | Obligate | Mist/soak late day; must dry by morning. |
Orchids (Phalaenopsis, etc.) | Facultative | Night temperature drop (5–10 °C) + airy bark mix. ❗Thick-leaved orchids often switch to CAM, while many thin-leaved rainforest orchids stay C₃ |
Bromeliads (Guzmania, Aechmea) | Obligate | Keep water in central cup; roots need air. |
Pineapple | Obligate | Bright light, moderate water; classic CAM crop model. |
Hoya (Wax plants) | Partial | Let soil dry; airflow helps rhythm and flowering. ❗CAM expression in Hoya is partial; some species show only weak or facultative CAM. |
Snake plant | Weak | Beginner-proof; water sparingly, bright light speeds growth. |
ZZ plant | Weak/Stress | Rare watering only; rhizomes rot fast if kept wet. |
Yucca | Partial | Tough rosette; dry cycles and bright light. |
Clusia | Facultative | Runs C₃ in comfort; flips to CAM in drought or high light. |
Aquatic CAM plants (Isoëtes, Littorella) | Obligate/Facultative | Submerged species use CAM under low CO₂; niche but important. |
Epiphytic ferns (Pyrrosia, Platycerium) | Facultative | Use CAM on bark/rock; water sparingly, never soggy. |
➜ Grower takeaway: CAM plants appear in many forms — desert succulents, glossy “unkillables,” orchids, bromeliads, and even ferns or aquatic plants. What unites them is a nighttime rhythm of CO₂ uptake that makes them drought-tolerant, slower-growing, and more resilient indoors. Care is easier when you match that rhythm: bright days, cooler nights, dry-down cycles, and evening hydration for epiphytes.
What CAM Means for Plant Care
Light & Temperature – Keeping the Rhythm Intact
Bright light is non-negotiable. CAM plants evolved in deserts, rock faces, and exposed canopies. Without strong light, their slow metabolism crawls to a stop.
Cooler nights are key. Many orchids and epiphytes need a 5–10 °C drop between day and night. This reinforces their circadian CAM rhythm, prompting stomata to open and (in orchids) flowering to initiate.
Heat resilience. Unlike thin-leaved tropicals, CAM succulents won’t wilt in a heatwave. Closed stomata + acid reserves = photosynthesis continues even at >40 °C.
Cold caution. Most CAM houseplants are subtropical. A cold + wet combination (below 10 °C for many succulents) is more dangerous than drought.
Watering – Syncing With the Night Breath
Follow a wet–dry cycle. Water deeply, then let soil dry fully. Overwatering suffocates roots and disrupts the CAM rhythm.
Time it right. For epiphytes (orchids, Tillandsia, bromeliads), watering in late afternoon or evening aligns with open stomata and maximizes uptake. For succulents, time matters less — drainage matters more.
Dormancy awareness. In summer heat or winter low light, many CAM plants slip into CAM-idling (stomata closed day & night, metabolism slowed). Growth halts, water use plummets — watering heavily during this phase often kills them.
Practical rule: When in doubt, withhold water rather than overdo it. CAM plants evolved for scarcity.
🔗 If you struggle with watering cycles, our complete watering guide breaks down timing and depth for different plant types. The ultimate guide to watering houseplants
Substrate & Root Environment – Air Over Soggy Soil
Succulents & cacti: Use gritty, mineral mixes — e.g. pumice, sand, perlite. Roots need oxygen, not constant moisture.
Orchids: Bark chunks, sphagnum, or other airy substrates — never dense potting soil. Roots need air and rapid wet–dry turnover.
Tillandsia: No soil at all — just regular misting/soaking + airflow.
Common thread: All CAM plants demand oxygenated root zones. Wet compost suffocates them, regardless of type.
Humidity – Match the Native Habitat
Desert succulents: Prefer drier air; don’t need misting. Typical indoor humidity is fine.
Epiphytic CAM plants (orchids, bromeliads, air plants, hoyas): Thrive in moderate humidity + airflow, mimicking tree canopies. Stagnant, wet air = rot risk.
Care tip: Dry climate growers should mist epiphytes lightly in the evening; desert CAM plants don’t need it.
🔗 Learn more: How to care for epiphytes – from orchids to tillandsias
Feeding & Growth – Slow and Steady
Built-in speed limit. CAM plants only photosynthesise as long as their nightly CO₂ bank lasts. You can’t push faster growth with fertilizer.
Light feeding. Use dilute balanced fertilizer during active growth (spring–summer for most succulents, after flowering cycles for orchids). Too much fertilizer = salt stress, which ironically can push some into stress CAM mode.
Expectation setting. A jade plant that adds a few leaves a year is healthy. A Phalaenopsis orchid that blooms annually on schedule is thriving. Patience is part of CAM care.
🔗Looking for a feeding routine that works? Our fertilizer guide explains what to use and how to avoid common mistakes with indoor plants. Best fertilizer for houseplants
Troubleshooting – When CAM Plants “Act Strange”
Succulent stopped growing in summer? Likely CAM-idling from heat or drought. Reduce watering, wait for cooler nights.
Orchid won’t bloom? Missing a night temperature drop or evening hydration. Constant warmth blurs the CAM rhythm.
Snake plant thriving in dark corners? Weak CAM lets it coast, but growth remains minimal without bright light.
ZZ plant yellowing or rotting? Classic overwatering. Its rhizomes + weak CAM cannot handle soggy soil.
🔗 Rot in succulents or ZZ plants is usually root rot — here’s how to spot it early and save your plant: Root rot in houseplants: treatment and prevention
Quick Do’s & Don’ts
Do:
Give bright light and a clear day–night temperature contrast.
Let substrates dry thoroughly before rewatering.
Water/mist in the evening for epiphytes.
Use airy, fast-draining mixes.
Be patient — slow growth is normal.
Don’t:
Expect CAM plants to grow like tropical vines.
Keep them constantly wet — they evolved for scarcity.
Assume dormancy = sickness — often it’s CAM-idling.
Believe air-purification myths — the real benefit is drought resilience, not oxygen output.
➜ Grower takeaway: CAM plants are resilient because they evolved to run on scarcity. To keep them healthy indoors, match that rhythm: bright light, cooler nights, drying cycles, and airy roots. If you accept their pace, they’ll reward you with longevity and toughness that most houseplants can’t match. You can’t ‘force speed’ into a CAM plant with more fertilizer. CAM growth is inherently slower because CO₂ uptake is limited to the nightly ‘bank,’ but the actual rate ranges from near-C₃ levels in obligate succulents with ample water to far lower rates under stress (Winter & Smith 1996; Moreno-Villena et al. 2022).
CAM Beyond the Home: Agriculture & Climate Resilience
CAM Crops We Already Use
CAM isn’t just a houseplant curiosity — it underpins important food and fiber crops that succeed where conventional crops fail.
Pineapple (Ananas comosus)
Classic obligate CAM bromeliad.
Thrives in semi-arid tropics with minimal irrigation.
Genome sequencing has made pineapple a model for CAM genetics.
Agave (Agave spp.)
Obligate CAM succulents.
Provide tequila, mezcal, fibers (sisal, henequen), and sweeteners.
Cultivated on marginal, dry soils with little input.
Opuntia (Prickly pear cactus)
Obligate CAM cactus.
Grown for edible pads (nopales), fruit (tunas), and as livestock fodder in arid lands.
Tolerates extreme heat and low rainfall where pasture grasses fail.
Portulaca oleracea (Purslane)
Rare example of a C₄ plant that can add CAM under drought.
Nutritious edible green; demonstrates metabolic flexibility in action.
➜ Takeaway: These species prove CAM’s worth as a drought-survival engine in agriculture.
Bioenergy & Green Infrastructure
Biofuel crops: Agave and Opuntia are promising as high-biomass, low-water-input sources for renewable energy. They grow on marginal land unsuitable for cereals.
Green roofs and xeriscaping: CAM succulents dominate urban greening projects in dry climates. Their high water-use efficiency reduces irrigation demand.
Ecosystem engineers: Bromeliads (like tank-forming species) create water reservoirs that sustain insects and amphibians in tropical canopies. Cacti stabilize arid soils against erosion. In bromeliads, CAM doesn’t just save water — it stabilises the tiny ecosystems inside their leaf tanks. By regulating water chemistry and slowing evaporation, CAM helps these rosettes act as reservoirs for insects, frogs, and microbes high in the canopy. Similar effects are seen in orchids and epiphytic ferns, where CAM activity helps maintain microhabitats on bark or rock. This shows CAM is not only a survival tool for the plant itself but also a way of supporting whole communities in difficult environments.
CAM and the Future of Food Security
The challenge: Global agriculture consumes ~70% of freshwater withdrawals. Climate change is pushing many regions toward drought stress.
The opportunity: CAM plants achieve 3–6× higher water-use efficiency than C₃ crops, and remain productive in environments where traditional crops collapse.
Scientists are now exploring:
Genomic blueprints: Pineapple, Kalanchoë, agave, and orchid genomes reveal the convergent gene networks that underpin CAM.
Synthetic CAM: Recent experiments introduced parts of the CAM cycle into tobacco (Nicotiana), a proof of concept that partial CAM can be engineered.
Engineering staple crops: Ambitious projects aim to “CAM-ize” rice, wheat, or poplar. Barriers remain — CAM needs not just enzymes, but also succulence, vacuoles, and circadian regulation.
Facultative inspiration: By understanding how facultative CAM species flip between modes, breeders may design crops that activate CAM only under stress, balancing productivity and resilience.
Genomics and Synthetic CAM
Recent genome projects for pineapple, agave, kalanchoë, and orchids have revealed that CAM didn’t evolve from scratch each time but by re-using existing C₃ genes under new circadian control. Scientists are now testing “synthetic CAM” by moving parts of this cycle into C₃ crops. For example, experiments in tobacco showed that introducing CAM enzymes can shift carbon uptake patterns, though without succulent tissues the benefit is limited. Large vacuoles, thick cuticles, and a strong circadian rhythm are just as essential as the enzymes themselves. This means engineering CAM into rice or wheat is still a long-term goal, but facultative CAM species may inspire stress-responsive crop designs sooner.
CAM in a Changing Climate
How CAM plants respond to rising CO₂ and global warming is more complex than it seems. Elevated CO₂ can boost growth in some facultative CAM species, but in others it dampens the nightly acid cycle. High night-time temperatures can also blur circadian control, lowering CAM efficiency. This means future climates may benefit some CAM lineages while stressing others, depending on how well their rhythms hold up under warm nights and higher CO₂. Indoors, this has a small but real echo: weak CAM houseplants like snake plants or ZZ may shift their balance depending on CO₂ build-up in poorly ventilated rooms.
Reality Check — The Limits of CAM in Agriculture
Growth ceiling: Because CAM relies on nightly CO₂ storage, its maximum daily carbon fixation is lower than in C₃ and C₄ crops. This limits its suitability as a high-yield staple and makes it more valuable for survival crops or specialty products such as agave, pineapple, prickly pear and ornamental succulents (Borland et al. 2009; Mason et al. 2015).
Anatomical requirement: CAM efficiency depends on large vacuoles, succulent tissues and strong circadian regulation, not just the enzyme set. Attempts to engineer CAM into cereals show partial shifts, but without succulent anatomy the benefits are limited (Lim et al. 2019; Perron et al. 2024).
Contextual use: CAM crops will complement rather than replace existing staples. They are best suited to drought-prone, saline or marginal lands where traditional crops fail, and as models for designing stress-responsive traits in other plants (Winter & Smith 2022; Sage et al. 2023).”
➜ Grower takeaway: The same metabolism that makes your jade plant forgiving also sustains tequila, pineapple, and prickly pear in harsh landscapes — and could help design future crops for a hotter, drier planet.
Myths & Misconceptions About CAM Plants
“CAM plants clean the air at night.”
Claim: Snake plants and succulents release oxygen at night, purifying your bedroom air.
Reality: They do release oxygen in darkness, but the amount is far too small to alter room air quality. The “air-cleaning” idea is marketing hype (Surridge 2019).
Care takeaway: Value snake plants and other CAM species for their drought tolerance and toughness, not as air filters.
🔗Air purification is one of the most persistent myths — we explain what plants can and can’t do for indoor air quality: Do houseplants really purify indoor air?
“They don’t need watering.”
Claim: CAM plants can survive indefinitely without water.
Reality: CAM plants are highly water-efficient, not immortal. Without replenishment, reserves deplete and the plant shrivels (Cushman & Borland 2002; Lüttge 2004).
Care takeaway: Use deep watering followed by complete dry-downs. Survival is not the same as healthy growth.
“Extra fertilizer makes succulents grow faster.”
Claim: Feeding heavily overcomes their slow pace.
Reality: Growth is limited by how much CO₂ is stored overnight, not nutrients. Overfeeding only causes salt stress (Winter & Smith 1996).
Care takeaway: Fertilize lightly and occasionally. Patience is part of CAM care.
🔗Weakened succulents are also more prone to pests like scale — learn prevention and control, or how beneficial insects can help indoors: Scale insects on houseplants
“Orchids don’t need cooler nights.”
Claim: As long as orchids get light, they’ll flower.
Reality: Many epiphytic orchids (Phalaenopsis, Cattleya, Dendrobium) rely on a 5–10 °C night-time temperature drop to run CAM efficiently and to initiate blooms (Lin et al. 2006).
Care takeaway: Provide a clear day/night contrast if you want reliable flowering.
“If my succulent stops growing, it’s sick.”
Claim: Dormancy or stalls = poor care.
Reality: Many CAM plants enter CAM-idling in summer heat or winter low light. Metabolism slows, but they are not dying (Winter & Holtum 2014).
Care takeaway: Don’t force growth with water. Reduce watering and wait until conditions improve.
“All succulents use CAM.”
Claim: Every fleshy-leaved succulent is a CAM plant.
Reality: Most do, but not all. Some Sedum, Peperomia, and thin-leaved orchids remain strictly C₃ (Smith & Winter 1996; Holtum 2023).
Care takeaway: Don’t assume — verify species specifics.
“CAM plants photosynthesise at night, so light isn’t important.”
Claim: Since they take in CO₂ at night, they don’t need much light.
Reality: Night is only for CO₂ storage. Sugar production still requires daylight. No light = no growth (Winter & Smith 2022).
Care takeaway: Provide as much bright light as possible indoors.
📌 Quick Reference Table — Myths vs. Reality
Myth | Reality | Care Takeaway |
|---|---|---|
“CAM plants clean the air at night” | Oxygen release is trivial | Value resilience, not filtration |
“They don’t need watering” | Still need hydration cycles | Deep water + full dry-down |
“More fertilizer = faster growth” | Growth capped by nightly CO₂ storage | Fertilize lightly, be patient |
“Orchids don’t need cooler nights” | Many require a 5–10 °C drop | Provide day/night contrast |
“Succulent stopped growing = sick” | Often CAM-idling | Reduce water, wait |
“All succulents are CAM” | Most, but not all | Check species |
“Light doesn’t matter” | Light powers sugar production | Bright light essential |
➜ Grower takeaway: CAM isn’t “magic photosynthesis.” It’s a trade-off — water savings in exchange for slower growth. Once you understand that, care becomes straightforward.
❗ Clarifying notes:
Snake plants and ZZ plants do release oxygen at night, but the amounts are negligible. Their real value indoors is resilience.
Evening watering is best for epiphytic CAM plants like orchids and Tillandsia, since their stomata open at night. For desert succulents, timing matters far less — drainage and airflow are what prevent rot.
Not all orchids are CAM users. Rainforest orchids with thin leaves remain C₃. CAM orchids are usually those with thick leaves or pseudobulbs adapted to drought.
Conclusion: Living with Night-Breathing Plants
CAM photosynthesis isn’t a quirky footnote in plant biology. It’s the adaptation that lets succulents coast through drought, orchids flower after cool nights, and snake plants survive neglect that would kill most greenery. By “breathing” at night, these plants trade speed for survival — a rhythm tuned to scarcity.
For growers, that means patience is part of the pact. CAM plants won’t race to fill a pot, but they will endure, rewarding you with resilience and longevity.
Beyond your home, the same metabolism that keeps a jade plant thriving on a windowsill also drives crops like pineapple, agave, and prickly pear — and it’s inspiring scientists to design future foods and fuels for a hotter, drier planet.
When you sync your care with their rhythm — bright days, cooler nights, generous dry-downs — you’re not just keeping a plant alive. You’re tending one of nature’s most elegant survival strategies, a lineage of night-breathing survivors that embody endurance in the face of scarcity.
Glossary — Key Terms in CAM Photosynthesis
CAM (Crassulacean Acid Metabolism):
A photosynthetic pathway where plants take in CO₂ at night, store it as malic acid, and release it by day to make sugars.
C₃ Plants:
The most common group. Stomata open by day to capture CO₂. Most ferns, tropical foliage plants, and food crops fall here.
C₄ Plants:
Plants that concentrate CO₂ with a different biochemical cycle. Includes maize, sugarcane, and sorghum.
Stomata:
Tiny pores in leaves that open and close to exchange gases (CO₂ in, O₂ and water vapor out).
PEP Carboxylase (PEPC):
Key CAM enzyme that fixes CO₂ at night into organic acids.
Rubisco:
Central photosynthetic enzyme. In CAM plants, it uses CO₂ released from malic acid by day.
Malic Acid:
An organic acid stored in vacuoles overnight in CAM plants. Its breakdown releases CO₂ for photosynthesis in daylight.
Vacuole:
Large storage compartment inside plant cells. In CAM plants, it holds the nightly acid pool.
δ¹³C (Carbon Isotope Ratio):
A chemical fingerprint used to detect CAM activity. CAM species usually range from –29 to –11‰, overlapping with both C₃ (–34 to –24‰) and C₄ (–15 to –9‰) plants, depending on how much carbon is fixed at night.
Obligate CAM:
Species that always run CAM once tissues mature (e.g. most cacti, many agaves, aloes, and bromeliads).
Facultative CAM:
Species that behave as C₃ under comfort but switch to CAM under stress (drought, salinity, high light). Includes some Sedum, Clusia, Portulaca, and orchids.
CAM-Cycling:
Mode where stomata open little at night; respired CO₂ is re-fixed, reducing carbon loss.
CAM-Idling:
Extreme survival state where stomata remain closed day and night. The plant recycles internal CO₂ to stay alive with minimal water loss but halts growth.
Water-Use Efficiency (WUE):
A measure of carbon gain per unit of water lost. CAM plants achieve ~2.6–20 times (sometimes up to ~40 times) the efficiency of C₃ plants.
Circadian Rhythm:
A plant’s internal clock that controls timing of stomatal opening and enzyme activity across day and night.
Epiphyte:
A plant that grows on trees or rocks without soil. Many CAM orchids, bromeliads, and some ferns are epiphytes.
Succulence:
A growth form with thickened leaves or stems that store water (and in CAM plants, acids). Common in cacti, aloes, and agaves, but not all succulents use CAM.
🔗 Not all succulents are alike — explore the key differences between tropical “jungle” succulents and classic desert species. Differences between tropical and desert succulents
Sources and Further Reading:
Baikie, L., & Wey, et al. (2023). Photosynthesis re-wired on the pico-second timescale. Nature. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-023-05763-9
Black, C., & Osmond, C. B. (2004). Crassulacean acid metabolism photosynthesis: Working the night shift. Photosynthesis Research, 76(3), 329–341. https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1024978220193
Borland, A. M., Griffiths, H., Hartwell, J., & Smith, J. A. C. (2009). Exploiting the potential of plants with crassulacean acid metabolism for bioenergy production on marginal lands. Journal of Experimental Botany, 60(10), 2879–2896. https://doi.org/10.1093/jxb/erp118
Bräutigam, A., Schlüter, U., Eisenhut, M., & Gowik, U. (2017). On the evolutionary origin of CAM photosynthesis. Plant Physiology, 174(2), 473–477. https://doi.org/10.1104/pp.17.00195
Cushman, J. C., & Borland, A. M. (2002). Induction of crassulacean acid metabolism by water limitation. Plant, Cell & Environment, 25(3), 295–310. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.0016-8025.2001.00760.x
Dodd, A. N., Borland, A. M., Haslam, R. P., Griffiths, H., & Maxwell, K. (2002). Crassulacean acid metabolism: Plastic, fantastic. Journal of Experimental Botany, 53(369), 569–580. https://doi.org/10.1093/jexbot/53.369.569
Gilman, I. S., & Edwards, E. J. (2020). Crassulacean acid metabolism. Primer, 30(2), R57–R62. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2019.12.029
Heyduk, K. (2021). The genetic control of succulent leaf development. Current Opinion in Plant Biology, 59, 101978. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pbi.2020.11.003
Heyduk, K. (2022). Evolution of crassulacean acid metabolism in response to the environment: Past, present, and future. Plant Physiology, 190(1), 19–30. https://doi.org/10.1093/plphys/kiac303
Holtum, J. A. M., & Winter, K. (1999). Degrees of crassulacean acid metabolism in tropical epiphytic and lithophytic ferns. Functional Plant Biology, 26(7), 749–757. https://doi.org/10.1071/PP99001
Holtum, J. A. M., Hancock, L. P., Edwards, E. J., & Winter, K. (2017). Facultative CAM photosynthesis in four species of Calandrinia, ephemeral succulents of arid Australia. Photosynthesis Research, 134, 17–25. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11120-017-0359-x
Holtum, J. A. M. (2023). The diverse diaspora of CAM: A pole-to-pole sketch. Annals of Botany, 132(4), 597–625. https://doi.org/10.1093/aob/mcad067
Hultine, K. R., Cushman, J. C., & Williams, D. G. (2019). New perspectives on crassulacean acid metabolism biology. Journal of Experimental Botany, 70(022), 6489–6493. https://doi.org/10.1093/jxb/erz465
Jiménez, M. S., Morales, D., & Irarte, J. (1983). Succulence and CAM relationships in Aeonium genus. Photosynthesis Research, 4, 9–20. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00041797
Lin, Q., Abe, S., Nose, A., Sunami, A., & Kawamitsu, Y. (2006). Effects of high night temperature on crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) photosynthesis of Kalanchoë pinnata and Ananas comosus. Plant Production Science, 9(1), 10–19. https://doi.org/10.1626/pps.9.10
Lim, S. D., Lee, S., Choi, W.-G., Yim, W. C., & Cushman, J. C. (2019). Laying the foundation for crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) biodesign: Expression of the C4 metabolism cycle genes of CAM in Arabidopsis. Frontiers in Plant Science, 10, 101. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpls.2019.00101
Lüttge, U. (2004). Ecophysiology of crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM). Annals of Botany, 93(6), 629–652. https://doi.org/10.1093/aob/mch087
Mason, P. M., Glover, K., Smith, J. A. C., Willis, K. J., Woods, J., & Thompson, I. P. (2015). The potential of CAM crops as a globally significant bioenergy resource: Moving from ‘fuel or food’ to ‘fuel and more food’. Energy & Environmental Science, 8, 2320–2329. https://doi.org/10.1039/C5EE00242G
Matiz, A., Tamaso, P., Yepes, A., Freschi, L., & Mercier, H. (2013). CAM photosynthesis in bromeliads and agaves: What can we learn from these plants? InTech. https://doi.org/10.5772/56219
Moreno-Villena, J. J., et al. (2022). Spatial resolution of an integrated C4+CAM photosynthetic metabolism. Science Advances, 8, eabn2349. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.abn2349
Orlov, N. (2024). Epiphytic succulents and CAM-photosynthesis. Modern Science Updates, 7(21), 110–113. https://doi.org/10.55959/MSU012039-4-2024-7-21
Osmond, C. B., Popp, M., & Robinson, S. A. (1996). Stoichiometric nightmares: Studies of photosynthetic O₂ and CO₂ exchanges in CAM plants. In K. Winter & J. A. C. Smith (Eds.), Crassulacean Acid Metabolism (Ecological Studies, Vol. 114, pp. 7–24). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-79060-7_2
Perron, N., Kirst, M., & Chen, S. (2024). Bringing CAM photosynthesis to the table: Paving the way for resilient and productive agricultural systems in a changing climate. Plant Communications, 5(3), 100772. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.xplc.2023.100772
Sage, R. F., Edwards, E. J., Heyduk, K., & Cushman, J. C. (2023). Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) at the crossroads: A special issue to honour 50 years of CAM research by Klaus Winter. Annals of Botany, 132(5), 553–561. https://doi.org/10.1093/aob/mcad160
Smith, J. A. C., & Winter, K. (1996). Taxonomic distribution of crassulacean acid metabolism. In K. Winter & J. A. C. Smith (Eds.), Crassulacean Acid Metabolism (Ecological Studies, Vol. 114, pp. 427–436). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-79060-7_27
Surridge, C. (2019). Uncovering cryptic CAM. Nature Plants, 5(1), 3. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41477-018-0351-2
Ting, I. P. (1989). Photosynthesis of arid and subtropical succulent plants. Aliso: A Journal of Systematic and Floristic Botany, 12(2), 387–406. https://scholarship.claremont.edu/aliso/vol12/iss2/14
Von Willert, D. J., Brinckmann, E., & Eller, B. M. (1983). CO₂ exchange of CAM-exhibiting succulents in the southern Namib Desert in relation to microclimate and water stress. Photosynthesis Research, 4, 289–298. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00052133
Winter, K., & Holtum, J. A. M. (2014). Facultative crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) plants: Powerful tools for unravelling the functional elements of CAM photosynthesis. Journal of Experimental Botany, 65(13), 3425–3441. https://doi.org/10.1093/jxb/eru063
Winter, K., & Holtum, J. A. M., & Smith, J. A. C. (2015). Crassulacean acid metabolism: A continuous or discrete trait? New Phytologist, 208(1), 73–78. https://doi.org/10.1111/nph.13446
Winter, K., & Smith, J. A. C. (1996). An introduction to crassulacean acid metabolism: Biochemical principles and ecological diversity. In K. Winter & J. A. C. Smith (Eds.), Crassulacean Acid Metabolism (Ecological Studies, Vol. 114, pp. 1–13). Springer. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-79060-7_1
Winter, K., & Smith, J. A. C. (2022). CAM photosynthesis: The acid test. New Phytologist, 233(2), 599–609. https://doi.org/10.1111/nph.17790
Yuan, G., Hassan, M. M., Liu, D., Lim, S. D., Yim, W. C., Cushman, J. C., Markel, K., Shih, P. M., Lu, H., & Yang, X. (2020). Biosystems design to accelerate C3-to-CAM progression. BioDesign Research, 2020, 3686791. https://doi.org/10.34133/2020/3686791
Comments